UnitedHealthcare/PacifiCare was penalized $800,000. Health Net and Kaiser were fined $750,000 each, and Cigna was assessed $450,000. State regulators said the size of the fines was determined by the volume of each plan's business in California and the severity of its violations.
The health plans must compensate providers for money they are owed, including penalties and interest, within six months. The plans must reopen their records dating back two to three years to their last financial review by the state. The state agency reviewed samples of claims after providers who serve members of health maintenance organizations complained about problems. Auditors said none of the plans met a state legal requirement to pay 95% of their claims correctly. More than 21 million Californians have HMO coverage. The reviews also found that most of the health plans lacked adequate procedures for settling disputes with providers. In some cases, health plan workers responsible for processing claims also oversaw appeals.